7 Plates That Will Have You Begging for More Nantucket Food

We know our tiny Atlantic island boasts some of the most renowned restaurants and culinary works in the world, but where do you start? We have everything you need to know about where to go and what to order that is guaranteed to show you why Nantucket food stands above the rest. Start mapping out your culinary tour for your next trip to the island. 

For additional recommendations on restaurants, things to do, and travel planning ideas for your trip, be sure to access our exclusive Vacation Guide. Our complimentary guide is sure to simplify your vacation planning!

Get the Guide

Where to Find the Best Nantucket Food

Don’t waste time reading reviews when you could be overindulging on oysters on the half shell. We have seven meals that every foodie needs to add to their dining bucket list. 

 

Find the Most Important Meal of the Day

 

  • Black-Eyed Susan’s

eggs benedict black eyed susansBlack-Eyed Susan’s is a long-running diner in the heart of Downtown Nantucket. Think less chic and more hometown when you’re planning your breakfast trip to this spot. Get there early, as lines form quickly, find your place at the bar or snag a table outside, and fill up on classic favorites. 

You can’t go wrong with any of their wholesome choices, but our favorite is the creamy, Hollandaise-smothered eggs benedict. The restaurant has a BYOB policy. Pair it with your favorite hard cider in the fall or sparkling wine in the summer, and you’ll be ready for a day of exploring the town.

  • The Downyflake

If you’re looking for a quick breakfast, look no further. You cannot leave the island without taking a warm, flakey bite out of The Downyflake’s homemade doughnuts. Grab a cup of Green Mountain Coffee and one of their maple glazed cake doughnuts, and satisfy your sweet tooth.

 

Where to Stop for Lunch

 

  • CRU Oyster Bar

Oysters CRU NantucketWalk with us to the end of the dock. Smell the salty sea air. Grab a glass of rosé. And indulge in pristinely shucked oysters at CRU Oyster Bar. We particularly love CRU at the lunch bell for its views of ferries and fishing boats gliding into the harbor. 

Obviously, you’ll want to get an order of oysters so check the revolving oyster card for daily selections. Also, CRU’s caviar selections are wonderfully paired with crème fraîche, toasted brioche, and butter-covered raw oysters.

  • Something Natural

If you’re on your way to the beach, make a stop at Something Natural right next to Coffin Park. The organic sandwich shop offers house-crafted lemonades, thick, tasty sandwich options, and homemade bread. We have to stick to our New England roots with a chilled, lobster salad sandwich from this traditional Nantucket cafe. It’s refreshing, filling, and fresher than you’ll ever find on the mainland.  

 

Indulge in a Five-Star Dinner

 

  • Via Mare

scallops at Via Mare Greydon HouseGreydon’s go-to restaurant, Via Mare, boasts progressive twists on traditional American dishes. Via Mare is one of the only spots on the island that flawlessly blends a refined, intimate, and elegant five-star atmosphere with a relaxed Bohemian vibe.

We may be biased, but you truly can’t go wrong with anything from Chef Marcus Ware. However, one of our very favorites is the utterly delectable and fresh pan-seared scallops. Paired with a buttery chardonnay, you’ll want to sit and simmer. It’s Nantucket food at it’s finest.

  • Òran Mór

Òran Mór is one of the most intimate spots on the island and serves up entrees fit for the finest. Ingredients are locally sourced, service is impeccable, and the atmosphere makes for the perfect date night. The Long Island Duck Breast is expertly crafted with spring onion, peaches, a honey glaze, warm duck confit, potato hash, and topped with Calabrian pepper salsa.

 

Unwind in the Comforts of Greydon House

Rooms-Federal Suite - EntranceWhen you can’t possibly eat anymore, come back to the Greydon House for the night. Book your stay in The Federal Suite and enjoy a private, residential-style entrance, high ceilings, a queen-sized bed, and views of the cobblestone streets. Live like a local in this classically sophisticated, spacious suite. We can’t wait to welcome you to Greydon House!